+1 to what @Slamtilt said. I am glad this was not broadcast.
1 Like
Im not entirely convinced thatās necessary. I feel like there is enough talent available within each region that we wouldnāt need a dedicated team to go all over the place. Not to mention that the sponsorship to support the endeavor would be nearly impossible to capture.
Some of the better streams out there have a mix of people in the booth from all over the country. I would pay money to be able to call a round with Greg Dunlap at every tournament. Steven Bowden Was basically born in a broadcast booth. There are far more examples of people who do an excellent job, but I pointed out those two for the sake of example.
This is where my earlier point about standardizing things comes in; if you can set the expectation and come to a consensus on how things are to be done based on internal and external feedback, you donāt have to scramble to find people to make a decent broadcast. Even if you donāt have āa-listā (sorry b-list booth peopleā¦ suckers) you can meet with the team pre-broadcast and give a rundown of what to do, what to expect, etcā¦ something like this may also help to groom not-so-experienced commentators into being phenomenal commenters. The same could be said of producers and the overall production itself.
1 Like
Banner not enough for you? Lol
And all this time I was blown away by how mega supportive everyoneās wives/significant others were. (Iāll be needing that number, too Karl. PM me.)
LOL, LMAO and LMFAO donāt pay this statement justice . . . I need something BIGGER than LMFAO 
You do an incredible job, and obviously should be at the top of anyoneās list.
This isā¦an interesting suggestion. I bet there are a few people each event who would payā¦$100? $50? to be in the booth for a round.
Ive spent a lot of time in the booth, and at either PAPA19 or PAPA20, I was with Greg and he just made it so easy. He was awesome to work with. I was basically saying I loved it so much, Iād pay to do it again hahaha. It is an interesting thing to consider! You pay US ago work! 
1 Like
Of course, it would be pitched differently, like buying a VIP pass for the event.
$200 gets you: entry to the tournament, and a guaranteed round of live tournament commentary in the booth with pinball champion Bowen Kerins!
I donāt
1 Like
Hahaha. I was referring to the streaming, organizing, software side of things.
1 Like
Yes, but the decision not to follow that match was made before it began when one couldnāt* have known it was going to be a poor game. Just because a process had a good outcome doesnāt mean itās a good process.
* Ok, maybe people here are thinkin they knew ahead of time what was going to happen in that match and they didnāt want that on camera. IF thatās what people are implying but not saying then I agree it may not be the best example. But there are plenty of times groups are chosen based on relatively random things like āWe showed that machine a lotā or āI know that person so letās follow themā instead of the best matches or any coherent storyline.
I can definitely agree with this point of view.
1 Like
Iāll also say that the PAPA crew in general does a very good job of trying to follow captivating games. The Belsito run from a few years ago rings a bell. I know there are runners that are on the floor trying to keep up with those things, and we keep those notes. Your point is still very valid though and well taken.
2 Likes
I would love to do commentary and think I could be pretty good at it. I just canāt bring myself to not play. Haha
1 Like
Thatās always my problem! I think announcing would be a bunch of fun, but darn if I donāt want to compete!
1 Like
I dunno, Iām interested enough in it that I would probably be willing to skip playing a tournament to be selected as a co-commentator on something.
I spend more time than Iād like to admit watching old broadcasts of things during lunch breaks. Currently working through the Pinburgh 2012 quarterfinal groups.
2 Likes
How about one or two great commentators doing it remotely from home? There could be a couple players or spectators on location texting with the commentators to deal with logistics as needed. It would still be good to give commentators some compensation if possible, but wouldnāt need as large of a budget since there is no travel.
Itās a good thought and itās been discussed. There are multiple issues:
-
the technical aspect making sure that the stream is completely in sync. Instead of dealing with a single output latency, now you you have two to three to handle and that can get messy fast.
-
you introduce new lines of error/breakdown into the system. If someoneās internet goes out, mic breaks, computer fails, etcā¦ you leave the other person hanging and if there is no other person, you get silence.
3 Likes
Qualifying and finals of a tournament at my house yesterday. I think Scott V (main commentator) did a great job. I wanted to have one other person as more of the rules nut, but all those that we had in attendance were playing. Iād love to hear peopleās thoughts.
Thanks!
2 Likes
Scott was smooth! He reminded me of Jim Nantz. Professional. The stream itself was one of the most professional streams I have seen outside of a couple of the major papa events. The only thing I would add is during the finals is have a total score for each player after each game. That way if I have to step away or Iām doing something else and look back at the screen I can immediately determine whatās going on within the game. For example your final game on Tron went down to ball three and it wouldāve been great to do the math to see who needed what just by looking at the screen. But Iām really picking needles out of a haystack. It was a tremendously impressive stream.
3 Likes